Pomona College Magazine
Volume 41. No. 2.
Issue Home
Past Issues
Pomona College Home
Related Links
 Keirsey's Web
 Take the Sorter
·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·
Pomona College Magazine is published three times a year by Pomona College
550 N. College Ave, Claremont, CA 91711

Online Editor: Mark Kendall

For editorial matters:
Editor: Mark Wood
Phone: (909) 621-8158
Fax: (909) 621-8203

PCM Editorial Guidelines

Contact Alumni Records for changes of address, class notes, or notice of births or deaths.
Phone: (909) 621-8635
Fax: (909) 621-8535
Email: alumni@pomona.edu
·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·   ·



Sorting Temperaments

By Mark Kendall

Psychologist David Keirsey ’47 believes there are four kinds of people in this world.

You’re an Artisan, Guardian, Idealist or Rational.

You’re born that way.

And you’re OK.

Keirsey’s “Temperament Sorter” is wildly popular with those disposed to self-analysis. Reader reviews for his book, Please Understand Me, on amazon.com run from “if I had just known this earlier, it would have saved me so much trouble” to “if everybody had the chance to read just one book …”

“Over the decades, I have received hundreds of letters from people who say, ‘You changed my life,’’’ says Keirsey, who published his first tome on the subject in 1978. Since then, Please Understand Me (written with Marilyn Bates) has sold more than two million copies and Keirsey has published a more detailed follow-up, Please Understand Me II, and several other books. A few years back, the Duluth (Minn.) News Tribune asked candidates for City Council to take the test and published the results.


Psychologist David Keirsey '47, seen above
and below, is ever-expressive with his
hands as he explains temperament theory.
   
Today, at age 84, Keirsey carries on his quest to hone and propagate his ideas. He types away at his next book, Brains and Temperaments, six days a week, eight hours a day, or until his eyes give him trouble. “I cannot not do it” he says. “I’m obsessed with it. Besides, it’s fun.”

The Keirsey Temperament Sorter is a 70-question inventory that identifies key character traits. Certain combinations of traits define the four temperaments and what Keirsey calls the 16 “role variants”:

-- Cheerful, fun-loving, excitable Artisans, are born with tactical brains, and gradually become efficient in playing the role of promoter, crafter, performer or composer.
-- Serious, dutiful, cautious Guardians, are born with logistical brains, and steadfastly become efficient in playing the role of supervisor, inspector, supplier or protector.
-- Dramatic, romantic, enthusiastic Idealists, are born with diplomatic brains, ever seeking to increase their efficiency in the role of educator, adviser, advocator or conciliator.
-- Pragmatic, scientific, technical Rationals, are born with strategic brains, systematically increasing their efficiency in the role of mobilizer, planner, remodeler or designer.
The sorter is meant to help people understand their mates, family members, friends, and co-workers rather than trying to change them. “It’s OK to be different,” Keirsey says. “That’s the message.”

The people who appreciate his theories the most are Idealists, the group that makes up less than 10 percent of the population. Keirsey says the conciliators within this group often grow up seeing themselves as ugly ducklings. “But they’re swans,” he says. “They just don’t know it.”

Kelley Hunt, a reference librarian in Conroe, Texas, first took the Keirsey Temperament Sorter more than a decade ago when she worked for a state agency. Learning about the different kinds of personalities was a very validating experience for Hunt, who turned out to be a rare Rational Planner.

“It just kind of makes you feel included in the human race, rather than a pariah,” said Hunt, who later took the Sorter a second time as part of her library job. “I always felt there was something wrong and I needed to change to be like other people. Now I feel like ‘this is the way I am.’”

The arena where Keirsey’s ideas get less acclaim is in academia. “It’s people out on the streets who have paid rapt attention,” he says. “Psychology departments have totally ignored it. Maybe they don’t like mavericks like me.”

Keirsey traces the origins of temperament theory back to the Greeks Hippocrates, Aristotle and Plato, who each outlined four basic temperaments. Later, 20th-century researchers such as Ernst Kretschmer, Eric Fromm and Isabel Myers also delved into what is now called “personology.”

Keirsey was turned on to the topic after a friend introduced him to the now widely-used Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. Upon taking the indicator he said “wow, that’s me.”

But Keirsey wanted to take it farther. He went to work elaborating on Isabel Myers’s model, (which itself was influenced by the earlier work of Carl Jung), to create his Temperament Sorter. The major difference, says Keirsey, is that while Myers focuses on what people “have in mind,” he focuses on “what people say and do.”

Keirsey, who scores as a Rational on his own temperament sorter, is more likely to watch someone’s hands than try to probe their mind. “Nobody can observe thoughts and feelings, so I’m no longer interested in guessing what they might be,” he says. So Keirsey has turned away from psychology and toward sociobiology, his current inspirations being sociologist Erving Goffman and communication analyst Jay Haley.

Being interviewed, Keirsey often answers questions by getting up from his desk, pulling a book from his library and expounding on its contents. He holds up a copy of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, the primary diagnostic reference used by mental health professionals in the U.S., and dismisses it as “drivel.”

The former fighter pilot often trains his sights on modern psychotherapy. He contends that there’s no such thing as mental illness. He considers the label “attention deficit” to be silly, and calls the widespread use of Ritalin a tragedy. He appears to relish his self-described role as a “maverick.”

Keirsey’s oldest daughter, Janene, a Rational like her father, fondly recalls the dinner-table discussions they had growing up, using salt and pepper shakers as props in their discussions of whether a set can be a subset of itself. Her father can be aggressive in making his arguments, Janene says, but she took this as a sign of respect, that he believed she, a child, was capable of defending her ideas. “He’s a formidable man,” she says, adding that he also was a “really good dad.”

Keirsey’s son, David Mark, also is a Rational with a Ph.D. in computer science. The father and son are both into science, technology and personology, and “argue with each other endlessly,” according to Keirsey.

His younger daughter, Tamara, is busy raising four of Keirsey’s eight grandchildren.
Keirsey’s own childhood was quite different. He grew up on a ranch in the then-rural town of Tustin, not far from his current home on the coast in Orange County. “I was in fantasy most of the time daydreaming,” he recalls. “There were no playmates. I was just isolated, so I read and daydreamed.”

At Santa Ana Junior College, he met his future wife, Alice. She was the first person he had met who would discuss philosophy with him. (After graduating from UCLA, she became an elementary school teacher.)

But college and courtship were interrupted by World War II, where he served a stint as a fighter pilot on a carrier in the Pacific theatre. With little tolerance for bureaucracy, Keirsey says his military years were a boring waste of time, except for the practices in aerobatics, rocket firing and dog-fighting, and the perilous combat missions at Okinawa, Borneo and the Ryuku Islands.

Out of the service, he married Alice and transferred to Pomona College for his last year and a half of college. He was determined to make up for lost time. “I read, read, read, read and read about psychology,” he said. From there he went on to earn his master’s and doctoral degrees at The Claremont Graduate School, where Professor Francis Theodore Perkins, a devotee of Gestalt psychology, was a major influence on him.

Keirsey began his work life as a counselor at a reform school for delinquent boys, and later worked for school districts helping “troubled and troublesome” kids stop being troubled or troublesome. In these roles, he developed his focus on changing what kids, parents, teachers, and administrators say and do, through the years collecting methods of correcting “deviant habits that children acquire in self defense.”

In 1970, he returned to academia as a professor at California State University, Fullerton, where he developed a program for training marriage, child, and family counselors and school psychologists in corrective counseling. He chaired the Counseling Department before “retiring” in 1981.

“I really didn’t retire,” he says. “I started writing in 1981 and have been writing ever since.”
Keirsey publishes through his family-run Prometheus Nemesis Books. This way, Keirsey says, he can focus on writing without having to worry about finding a publisher. And write he does, day after day, surrounded by books in his study. “He’s never quite satisfied that he’s got it completely,” says daughter Janene, who works for Prometheus Nemesis.

At the moment, he’s hammering away at his next book, tentatively titled Brains and Temperaments: An Inquiry into the Division of Labor in Civilization. This tome will put a twist on his temperament theory, presenting it as four kinds of brains—strategic, tactical, logistical and diplomatic.

He scrolls down on his computer screen to reveal bar charts that show the relative strength of these four brains. “I have a strategic brain, so my logistical brain doesn’t work very well,” he says. “And, besides, I’m not interested in logistics, that is, collecting, stashing, and distributing wares, goods and commodities.”

These differing kinds of brains, Keirsey says, trace back to caveman era roles of hunter, gatherer, shaman and toolmaker. He sees the different temperaments as necessary for the division of labor in society today. “You’re born with a certain kind of brain, so go with it,” he says. “Do what you do best. Find that niche that suits your best suit.”

That ideology serves Keirsey well as he reaches his mid-80s, with his brain still focused on refining his work. Along with the nearly-completed Brains and Temperaments, Keirsey already has written more than 400 pages of a book on madness and temperament. After that, he plans a book on logic, and then one on how to reshape education to accommodate the different brains.

“My goal,” he says. “Is to stay alive long enough to get my books written.”

Know the types:

The Rational: Pragmatic, scientific, technical, born with a strategic brain, with Einstein as the classic example.
The Idealist: dramatic, romantic, enthusiastic, born with a diplomatic brain. Example: Gandhi.
The Artisan: cheerful, fun-loving, excitable, born with a tactical brain. Example: Ernest Hemingway.
The Guardian: serious, dutiful, cautious, born with a logistical brain. Example: Mother Teresa.

Pomona Personalities


Psychologist David Keirsey ’47 finds that two of his four personality types are far more common than the others. He estimates that Guardians make up 40 to 45 percent of the population while Artisans account for 35 to 40 percent. Idealists make up no more than 10 percent of the population and Rationals fewer than 7 percent.

Recently, an unscientifically selected sample of Pomona alumni, students, faculty and staff took the test in response to a request from PCM. Not surprisingly, the steadfast, logistical-brained, institution-protecting Guardians make up an even larger percentage (52 percent) of those who agreed to take the test than Keirsey’s averages: Idealists made up 16 percent, Rationals 8 percent and Artisans 8 percent.

Several of our respondents commented on the difficulty they had in choosing answers at many points in the sorter, and one, Professor James Likens, actually took the test three times, recording different results each time, so that he enters the books as an Idealist/Rational/Artisan—or maybe he would be best described as an anti-Guardian. At least, until he takes the test for the fourth time...

For what it’s worth, here’s a sample of Pomona personality types:

Artisans
Bill Keller ’70, executive editor, The New York Times, trustee
Jan Gore Venolia ’50, author

Idealists
Leonard Pronko, professor of theatre
Mary Schmich ’79, columnist, Chicago Tribune
Margo True ’86, executive editor, Saveur
Mark Wood, executive editor, PCM

Rationals
Kathleen Howe, director, Pomona College Museum of Art
Bruce Poch, dean of admissions
Ann Quinley, dean of students

Guardians
Cecilia Conrad, associate dean of the college, professor of economics
Lori DesRocher ’06, ASPC president
Jennifer Doudna ’85, professor of chemistry, UC Berkeley; trustee
Neil Gerard, director of Smith Campus Center
Gary Kates, dean of the college
Dan O’Leary, associate professor of chemistry
David Oxtoby, president
Gregg Popovich, former basketball coach; head coach, San Antonio Spurs
Jill Walker Robinson, managing editor, PCM
Cynthia Selassie, professor of chemistry
Jim Taylor ’84, screenwriter
Nancy Treser-Osgood ’80, director of alumni relations
Sam Yamashita, professor of history
©Copyright 2004
by Pomona College
Top of Page Pomona College Magazine • 550 N. College Ave, Claremont, CA 91711 • Contact us for editorial matters